News Flash
  • Postponement of Two Days' Training Workshop on " Data Analytics in Government for Development of Economic/Business Intelligence" Scheduled on 25th & 26th June, 2018 at NACIN, Faridabad Click here
  • Circular modifying the procedure for interception of conveyances issued Click here
  • Details of Prospective Trainings By NACIN and its ZTIs & RTIs in July, 2018 Click here
  • CGST Rules, 2017 as amended upto 19.06.2018 have been uploaded
  • Notification issued for amending the CGST Rules, 2017
  • Weekly newsletter from Chairman, CBEC dated 15/06/2018. Click here
  • Updated version of GST Concept and Status and PPT on GST - An Update as on 01/06/2018 have been uploaded.
  • Circulars clarifying miscellaneous issues related to SEZ and refund of unutilized ITC for job workers
  • Two Days' Training Programme on Free Trade Agreements for Group 'A' officers of CBIC on 28th & 29th June, 2018 at NACIN, Faridabad.Click here
  • CGST Rules, 2017 as amended upto 13.06.2018 have been uploaded
  • Notifications issued for amending the CGST Rules, 2017, and for specifying the list of goods which may be disposed off by the proper officer post seizure.
  • Renaming of Directorate General of Safeguards as Directorate General of Anti-profiteering.
  • Draft RRs for the post of Supdt CEx in Directorates under CBIC - comments from stakeholders.Click here
  • The MPR for GST-Refund (DDM-GST-1A) has been hosted on DDM website. GST Commissionerates are required to upload the GST Refund data from July, 2017 to May, 2018 at the earliest.
  • Field formations are informed that from this month onwards, DPM-CUS-13 and DPM-CUS-13A are included in the Part-V (Adjudication, Call Book, Refunds, Provisional Assessments, Miscellaneous) which is to be uploaded from April, 18 onwards.
  • Three Days’ Training on ‘DIGITAL FORENSICS’ for Group-‘A’ Officers of CBIC From 02nd July to 04th July, 2018 at Gujarat Forensic Sciences University, GandhinagarClick here
  • Seniority list of Assistant Commissioner of Customs and Central Excise. For Details… Click here
  • Comments are invited for Draft Provisional Assessment regulations, 2018 on uscus4.dor@gov.in up to 15.6.18.Click here
  • FAQs on Financial Services Sector published.Click here
  • Details of Prospective Trainings By NACIN and its ZTIs & RTIs in June, 2018 .Click here
  • Notification issued for extending the due date of filing of FORM GSTR-6 for the months from July, 2017 to June, 2018.Click here
  • Clarification regarding service tax on ambulance services provided to government by private service providers.Click here
  • Clarification on refund related issues. Click here
  • Dear Taxpayer, web-help service is available now and you can get faster resolution of your query by clicking the "SELF SERVICE" option under "HELP" tab in the top right of CBIC website cbec-gst.gov.in
  • Departmental Examination for promotion of Ministerial Officers to be held from 08.08.2018 to 10.08.2018
  • Weekly newsletter from Chairman, CBEC dated 25/05/2018. Click here
  • Introduction of monetary limit at the level of Commissioner (appeals) Click here
  • Nominatioans are invited from the formations of Bengaluru Zone for the ‘Course on Drugs and Related Laws’ scheduled on 29.05.2018 and 30.05.2018 Click here
  • CBLR Written Wxamination Result held on 19.01.2018 Click here
  • Instruction regarding Suo Motu Trasfer of authorisations on behalf of Union of India by the Authorised Commissioners. Click here
  • DDM-GST-5 MPR (showing Revenue Augmentation) has been Operationalized on DDM website today. GST Commissionerates are required to start uploading the requisite data from the month of July,2017 upto April,2018 at the earliest.
  • Member (A)'s instructions regarding revision of pre-2016 Pensioners as per 7th CPC. Click here
  • One Day Workshop On " E-Way Bill Systems" for the Group 'A' Officers of CBIC on 08th June, 2018 Click here
  • Notification issued for extending the due date of filing of FORM GSTR-3B for the month of April, 2018. Click here
  • Diversion of the posts of Principal Chief Commissioners of CBEC on their promotion. Click here
  • Draft Integrated All India Seniority List of Administrative Officers of Customs for the period 01.07.2014 to 31.12.2016 Click here
  • Positive Change through Emotional Intelligence and Personality Development Click here
  • Grievance Redressal Officers (CBIC and State / UT Governments) for e-way bill system under rule 138D of Central/ State GST Rules, 2017 Click here
  • Circular on applicability of POPS to development of software and services on software issued - Click here
  • Change of Date Of "Two Days' Training Programme On Free Trade Agreement, Possible Misuse & Redressal Mechanism" from 14th & 15th May to 28th & 29th June, 2018 Click here
  • Annual General Transfer 2018 Circular Click here
  • Wider participation of citizens/public/employees is requested in taking online Integrity Pledge. For taking online Integrity Pledge please click here
  • Advisory on AIO functioning, connectivity issues for GST.-click here, TCS Escalatoin Matrix for GST Zones LAN Implementation, Wipro Handholders, HP Resident Engineers
View all

AUTHORITY FOR ADVANCE RULINGS
(CUSTOMS, CENTRAL EXCISE & SERVICE TAX)
NEW DELHI

PRESENT

Hon'ble Justice Syed Mohammed
Quadri
(Chairman)
Mr. Somnath Pal
(Member)
Dr. B.A.Agrawal
(Member

 

ORDER NO. AAR/CUS/07/04
Petition No.ROM/01/CUS/2004 IN
ADVANCE RULING NO. AAR(CUS)/01/2004

 

  Petitioner M/s A. Tex(India) Private Ltd.
15/15, Sarvapriya Vihar
New Delhi - 110 016
Commissioner concerned Commissioner of Customs, Delhi
 Present for the petitioner Shri Ashok Dhingra,
Consultant       
CESTAT, Delhi 

   O  R  D  E  R
                  (By  Mr. Justice Syed Shah Mohammed Quadri)

            The Petitioner in this petition under Rule 18 of the Authority for Advance Rulings (Procedural) Rules, 2003 (for short the "Rules") is the applicant in the application for advance ruling (AAR(Cus)/01/2004).  It seeks rectification of ruling pronounced by the Authority on the questions specified in the said application on 16.3.2004 on the ground it suffers from mistake apparent from the record. 

2.         Mr. Dhingra appearing for the petitioner, points out to us the portion of the ruling which according to him contains an error apparent from the record, which reads as follows:- 

 "It is fairly conceded before us by the applicant that none of these conditions are satisfied in this case.  If this be so, the benefit of the notification is not available to the applicant nor will it be available to purchasers from the applicant even though they may be utilizing the imported of goods in manufacturing other goods for exporting the same for the simple reason that admittedly they have not imported the goods in question".

Mr. Dhingra points out that the portion underscored contains the error on the face of the record.  He argues that apart from the applicant, the persons who purchase the goods from the applicant and get clearance from the customs will also be importers and would be end to the benefit of the notification and that the portion indicated above would affect the interest of all the purchasers of the applicant as they would also be bound by the ruling of this Authority.  He, however,  admits that the ruling is right having regard to the questions proposed by the applicant but adds that the questions themselves were framed in wide terms.

3.         Heard Shri A.K. Roy, Joint CDR for the Commissioner in application.

4.         In our view the petition is wholly without any merit.  First the portion pointed out above does not suffer from any mistake let alone mistake apparent on the record having regard to the scope of rule 18 which reads thus:

Rectification of mistakes  -
(1)        The Authority may, with a view to rectifying any mistake apparent from the record, amend any order passed by it before the ruling pronounced by the Authority has been given effect to by the assessing officer.

(2)       Such amendment may be made suo motu or when the mistake is brought to its notice by the applicant or the Commissioner, but only after following the applicant and the Commissioner a reasonable opportunity of being heard.

Rule 18 is analogous to Section 154 of the Income Tax Act.  Under the rule only such a mistake is liable to be rectified which is apparent from the record. Such a mistake as occurs due to accident or inadvertence, once your attention is invited to it, you cannot miss it.  If it requires debate,  long process of reasoning to discover the mistake, it cannot be a mistake apparent from the record.   The portion indicated above is a considered opinion expressed after examining the scope of the notification under which  goods  imported by a  manufacturer of specified  goods for use in the manufacture of such goods for export by that manufacturer alone enjoy the exemption; the benefit of the notification is not available to bona fide exporters of manufactured goods, who are purchasers from importers.  Secondly, section 28J of the Act, on which Mr. Dhingra also relies, makes it abundantly clear that the advance ruling pronounced by the Authority under section 28-I(6) shall be binding only on (a) the applicant who sought it; (b) in respect of matters referred to in sub-section(2) of section 28H and (c)  the Commissioner of Customs.  The purchasers or the would-be purchasers of the applicant do not fall under any of the above mentioned clauses, therefore, it would be futile to contend that under section 28J the ruling would be binding on the purchasers.  Whether purchasers of the applicant would step into the shoes of the applicant is a question which does not arise for our consideration here and we express no opinion on it.   Even according to Mr. Dhingra, the ruling is correct on the basis of the question mentioned in the application but the question was not properly framed.  This being the real position, rule 18 will not be applicable as error cannot be said to be apparent from the record.

5.         In the result the petition is without any merit and is accordingly dismissed.

Sd/     
(Somnath Pal)
Member 
 Sd/ 
(Justice S.S.M. Quadri) 
Chairman
Sd/
(B.A. Agrawal) 
Member

 

New Delhi
Date:25-11-2004