News Flash
  • Details of the JHT 2017 Candidates who have not joined the Department - Click here
  • Result of Examination of GST Practitioners held on 31.10.2018 Click here
  • GST HINDI LEXICON IS AVAILABLE NOW.
  • Diversion of the posts of Chief Commissioners on promotion of Pr. Comm./Pr. ADG Click here
  • OM dated 12.12.2018 regarding AISL of Administrative Officers (Cx & Dte.) for the period upto 2008 Click here
  • Promotion/Posting/Transfer order of Group 'A' officers of CRCL Click here
  • Removal of difficulty order regarding extension of due date for filing of Annual return (in FORMs GSTR-9, GSTR-9A and GSTR-9C) for FY 2017-18 till 31st March, 2019 issued. -Click here -Click here
  • Draft integrated All India Seniority List of Superintendents of Customs (Prev.) for the period from 01.01.2012 to 31.12.2013 Click here
  • Chairman CBIC's weekly newsletter dated 07.12.2018 Click here
  • Due date for filing of Annual return for FY 2017-18 in FORMs GSTR-9, GSTR-9A and GSTR-9C extended to 31st March, 2019. Click here
  • Marks obtained in the Departmental Examination for promotion of LDC/Havaldar to the cadre of Tax Assistant for the year 2018-19, held on 20.07.2018 Click here
  • Revised All Industry Rates(AIRs) of Duty Drawback notified. For details refer to notification no. 95/2018-Cus. (N.T.) dated 6.12.2018. Click here
  • Diversion of the posts of Pr CC of CBIC on their promotion Click here
  • Letter from the office of DGHRD to all the CCAs regarding "Revised Online DPC Module" for Group 'B' and 'C Click here
  • Scheme for Prime Minister's Awards for Excellence in Public Administration - reg.Click here
  • Kind attention Pr. CC/CC/Pr. DG/DG/JS/Commissioner of CBIC is invited to DG Systems letter F. No. IV (20)/21 /2018-Systems dated 04.12.2018 regarding Business Requirement Gathering for Project ADVAITClick here
  • For GSTP Examination on 17.12.2018, candidates enrolled up-to 4.12.2018 (11.59.59 PM) will be eligible to register, instead of 26.11.2018, notified earlier English | Hindi
  • Updated version of GST Concept and Status and PPT on GST - An Update as on 01/12/2018 have been uploaded
  • Final Integrated All India Seniority List of Administrative Officers of (CGST & Dte.) for the period 01.07.2014 to 31.12.2016Click here
  • 21 countries along with WCO, Interpol, UNODC and RILO AP invited to the 5th Regional Customs Enforcement Meeting organized by DRI on 04.12.2018
  • DRI completing 61 Glorious Years. Hon'ble FM to inaugurate the 61st Founding Day function on 04.12.2018
  • GSTPs in the relevant category enrolled on GSTN after 15.11.2018 and till 26.11.2018 are also invited to register on the portal.Click here for English | Hindi
  • Updated FAQs On TCS as on 30/11/2018 issued
  • Notifications issued for extension of due date for filing certain GST returns.
  • Guidelines for Dept. Exam. of Inspectors for confirmation starting from 04.12.2018, issued on 29.11.2018. (Download by using user-id & password at www.nacenkanpur.gov.in)
  • Proposals are invited from eligible Bidders to be appointed as Program Governance and Monitoring Agency (PG&MA) for CBIC’s IT Initiatives. The RFP document can be purchased from the office of DG Systems and Data Management by Respondents who successfully qualified CBIC's EOI dated 26.03.2018 for this project. Click here
  • Postponement of Train the Trainer Workshop for Master Trainers on Combating illegal trade in HCFCs to be conducted from 03rd to 05th December, 2018 at Gangtok, Sikkim Click here
  • Details of Prospective Trainings by NACIN and its ZTIs & RTIs in December, 2018 Click here
  • One-day training programme on "Chemical Weapons Convention" for Group 'A' Officers of CBIC scheduled to be held on 30th November, 2018 at NACIN, Faridabad- Click here
  • Departmental Examination for promotion of Ministerial Officers to be held from 13.02.2019 to 15.02.2019. - Click here
  • Guidelines for GST Practitioner Exam under Rule 83A(9) issued by NACIN, Faridabad - Click here
  • GSTP Examination rescheduled to 17th December 2018 in view of assembly elections on 7th December, 2018 - Click here - Click here
  • Scheme for grant of Cash Awards to meritorious children of Departmental officers/ staff for their performance in the 10th/12th standard Board Examinations held in March/April, 2016, 2017 and 2018-Click here
  • Weekly newsletter from Chairman, CBIC dated 16/11/2018Click here
  • RESULT OF EXAMINATION OF GST PRACTITIONERS HELD ON 31.10.2018 - Click here
  • Call for nominations for workshop for South Asian Sub-regional Economic Co-operation (SASEC) Customs Administration on Trade Facilitation Measures for Time Release Study from 26-27 November, 2018 - Click here
  • Corrigendum of RFP Dated 10.10.2018 for orgainizing International Attachment on Public Policy and Leadership for the 69th Batch of IRS (C&CE) Officer Trainees - Click here
  • Corrigendum to Notification 60/2018-Central Taxes dated 30.10.2018 issued
  • Calling of nomination for the Train the Trainer Workshop for Master Trainers on combating illegal trade in HCFCs being conducted by NACIN from 03-05 Dec, 2018 at Gangtok, Sikkim - Click here
  • Feedback and Action Room to facilitate GST Helpdesk set-up by CBIC for MSMEs - Click here
  • Departmental Examination for IRS (C&CE) Group "A" Officer Trainees to be held from 26th November to 01st December, 2018 in respect of 69th and 68th batch - Click here
  • Updated versions of 3 publications on MSME namely MSME flier, Detailed Booklet and Sectoral Publication are available on the CBIC website-GST> My GST >MSME - Click here
  • Nodal Officers for MSME outreach program Click here
  • Letter from Commissioner (GST) regarding MSMEs outreach program - Click here
  • Swachhta Uday Booklet is available now.Click here
View all

AUTHORITY FOR ADVANCE RULINGS
(CUSTOMS, CENTRAL EXCISE & SERVICE TAX)
NEW DELHI

PRESENT

 

Hon'ble Mr.Justice Syed Shah
Mohammad Quadri (Chairman)
Mr. Somnath Pal (Member) Dr. B.A. Agrawal (Member)

 

Order No.AAR/CE/05/2004
Application No.AAR/104/CE/2004
 

 

Applicant M/s.Crystal Interior Products
Plot No.41, GIDC, Ichhapore
Sachin-Hazira Road,
Bhatpore Village,
Surat-394510
Commissioner concerned  Commissioner, Central Excise,
Surat-I
Present :  for the applicant for the Commissioner     concerned   Shri J.D.Shah, Advocate
 

Shri A.K. Roy, Joint CDR
CESTAT, New Delhi .

Shri Sanjay Singh, Supdt.
Central Excise Commissionerate
Surat-I

O R D E R
(Hon'ble Mr. Justice Syed Shah Mohammad Quadri)

 

   This is an application under section 23C of the Central Excise Act, 1944, (for short the "Act" ), seeking advance ruling of the Authority on the following question :-
Whether the products in question are classifiable under Chapter Heading 7323.90 or 7326.19 or any other Chapter Head or more than one Chapter Head.
2 . The applicant is a resident Indian partnership firm which is a S.S.I unit.  It claims to be in the process of setting up a joint venture.  It is engaged in the manufacture and sale of the iron and steel wire products.  It says that the products in question are classified by the excise department under Chapter heading 7326.19 and states that by its letter dated 7.4.2004, it has accepted the classification provisionally subject to final ruling by the Advance Rulings Authority, which the department has also accepted.
3. Heard the learned counsel for the applicant and the Commissioner.
4. After examining the application and the comments of the Commissioner, the Authority issued a  notice to the applicant on 4th June 2004 requiring the applicant to explain as to why the application should not be rejected on any one or more of the following grounds :-
  (i)  the details and documentary evidence in respect of the non-resident co-venturer in the proposed joint venture have not been provided in the application;
  (ii) the question raised in the application appears to fall under clause (a) of the first proviso to sub-section (2) of section 23D of the Act;
  (iii)  the applicant appears to have already commenced the activity of manufacture of goods which are the subject matter of the advance ruling application.
5. In so far as the first ground is concerned, the applicant has complied with the requirement of the notice.  Regarding grounds (ii) and (iii), the application is listed today for hearing the applicant and the Commissioner.
6. To appreciate the point involved in the second ground, it would be useful to refer to sub-section (2) of section 23D which is in the following terms:
  " (2) The Authority may, after examining the application and the records called for, by order, either allow or reject the application: Provided that the Authority shall not allow the application where the question raised in the application is, -
  (a) already pending in the applicant's case before any Central Excise Officer, the Appellate Tribunal or any Court;
  (b) the same as in a matter already decided by the Appellate Tribunal or any Court: Provided further that no application shall be rejected under this sub-section unless an opportunity has been given to the applicant of being heard: Provided also that where the application is rejected, reasons for such rejection shall be given in the order".
7. A perusal of the provisions, extracted above, would show that under clause (a) of the first proviso to sub-section (2) of section 23D, the Authority cannot allow the application (cannot entertain for pronouncing advance ruling under sub-section (4) thereof), if the question raised in the application is already pending in the applicant's case before any Central Excise Officer or Appellate Tribunal or any Court.  The letter of  the Assistant Commissioner of Central Excise, Division -IV, Surat-I dated 26th April 2004, addressed to the applicant implies that the question of classification is pending before the Division-IV, Surat-I.  The applicant, it appears, has approached the Commissioner for classification of the goods and addressed letters dated 29/11/2003 and 7/4/2004 .  It was in response to those letters that the aforementioned letter of the Assistant Commissioner was issued.  A reading of that letter as well as the letter of 25th May 2004 leaves no doubt in our mind that the question of classification is pending before the Central Excise Authority and a situation postulated in clause (a) of the first proviso to sub-section (2) of section 23D exists.   On this ground alone, the application is liable to be rejected.
8. However, as we have referred to ground (iii) in our notice, we would take up that point as well.  This relates to commencement of activity of manufacture of goods.  A reference to the definition of "advance ruling", in this connection, would be pertinent. Clause (b) of section 23A of the Act defines "advance ruling" thus:
    "advance ruling" means the determination, by the authority of a question of law or fact specified in the application regarding the liability to pay duty in relation to an activity proposed to be undertaken, by the applicant."
9. A plain reading of the definition makes it clear that "advance ruling" means the determination, by the Authority, of a question of law or fact specified in the application regarding liability to pay duty in relation to an activity proposed to be undertaken by the applicant.  The question that arises here is whether the applicant is at the stage of proposing to undertake the activity or has already commenced the activity of manufacture of goods.
     
10 In response to the letter issued by the Secretariat of the Authority on 14th May 2004, seeking clarification in that regard, the applicant replied by its letter dated 22nd May 2004. Para '4' of that letter is relevant here and reads thus -
    " 4.       The point regarding the manufacture of the excisable items for which advance ruling is applied, please refer to the statements of fact given with application in which we have stated that yes we do manufacture the said goods at present."(emphasis supplied)
10. It is categorically admitted in the para, referred to above, that the applicant has already started manufacturing the goods in question. In view of this factual position, the activity cannot be said to be an activity proposed to be undertaken.  Therefore, in respect of the aforementioned goods, no question seeking advance ruling can be entertained by the Authority.
11. For the aforementioned reasons, we reject the application.

 

Sd/-
(Somnath Pal)
Member
Sd/-
(Justice S.S.M.Quadri)
Chairman
 Sd/-
(B.A.Agrawal)
Member  

Dated 12th October, 2004.

F.No.AAR/44/104/04