News Flash
  • Weekly newsletter from Chairman, CBEC dated 20/04/2018. Click here
  • Inviting Nominations for Two Days' Training Workshop on Preservation of Heritage Buildings for Group A Officers of CBIC on 21 and 22 May, 2018 Click here
  • CGST Rules, 2017 as amended upto 18.04.2018 have been uploaded. Click here
  • Details of Vendors providing E-seals as per Circular 36/2017-Customs & 37/2017-Customs Click here
  • Training on "Expenditure Management & Budget Planning" on 23.04.2018(Monday)by EMC, DGHRD at NACIN, Faridabad.Click here
  • Weekly newsletter from Chairman, CBEC dated 13/04/2018 Click here
  • "Circulars clarifying the procedure for interception of conveyances for inspection of goods in movement, and detention, release and confiscation; recovery of arrears under the existing law and reversal of inadmissible input tax credit issued; and clarification of issues in refund to UIN." Click here
  • " Seeking views/ suggestions and data for review of All Industry Rates (AIRs) of Duty Drawback for the year 2018- letter to Export Promotion Councils/ Commodity Boards/ Trade and Industry Associations/ Chambers of Commerce."Click here
  • Inviting Nominations for One day Training Session on “Expenditure Management” at NACIN Faridabad for the Officers of the rank of Joint/Addl Commissioners/Commissioners/Pr. Commissioners of CBIC on 23rd April, 2018. Click here
  • "Clarification on issues related to furnishing of Bond / LUT for exports has been issued." Click here
  • Two Days’ Training on Establishment and Administration" at NACIN Faridabad for the Officers of the rank of Asstt. Commissioner to Addl. Commissioners of CBIC on 19th & 20th April, 2018 .Click here
  • Ban on Import of Oxytocin; stepping up vigilance mechanism in check smuggling of Oxytocin - Click here
  • Smooth roll out of e-Way Bill system from 01st April, 2018 - Click here
  • FAQs on e-way bill Click here
  • Appointment of Nodal Officer for PQs in Customs Zones Click here
  • Appointment of Nodal Officer for PQs in CGST Zones Click here
  • TOP Most priority to PQ repliesClick here
  • Circular clarifying export related refund issues issued
  • Advisory on AIO functioning, connectivity issues for GST.-click here, TCS Escalatoin Matrix for GST Zones LAN Implementation, Wipro Handholders, HP Resident Engineers
View all

F. No. 390/Misc/163/2010-JC

Government of India

Ministry of Finance  

Department of Revenue

 (Central Board of Excise & Customs)

INSTRUCTION

Dated:  26.12.2014

 

To,                                                                                                      

 

All Principal Chief Commissioners, Central Excise, Service Tax and Customs.

All Chief Commissioners of Central Excise, Service Tax and Customs.

Chief Commissioner/(AR), CESTAT, New Delhi.

All Commissioners of Central Excise, Service Tax and Customs.

All Commissioners (AR), New Delhi, Mumbai, Chennai, Kolkata, Bangalore & Ahmadabad.

Webmaster.

 

Sub:     Monetary limit for filing appeal in the Tribunal/Courts- - reg.

 

Sir / Madam,

 

Your attention is invited to Instruction of even number dated 20.10.2010 modified vide Instruction dated 17.8.2011 by which the Board had fixed monetary limits below which appeal shall not be filed in the Tribunal/Courts by the Department. As stated in the Instruction dated 17.8.2011, the present monetary limits are Rs 5 lakhs/Rs 10 lakhs/ Rs 25 lakhs respectively for appeal to be filed in the Tribunal/High Courts and the Supreme Court. Appeal is not required to be filed in cases below these monetary limits unless the dispute falls in the two exclusion category mentioned in para 3 of Instruction dated 17.8.2011.

 

2.         The Board has been receiving letters from the field seeking clarifications on various aspects relating to implementation of the Instructions governing monetary limits for filing appeal in the Tribunal and Courts. Mostly, the clarifications sought is  whether cases of recurring nature, whether involving the same party or even other parties, need to be pursued in litigation irrespective of the amount involved in such cases. The second issue relates to applicability of the threshold limits in various situations, mostly where the adjudicating/appellate authority disposes of more than one appeal in a common order which is sought to be challenged. Such order, generally involve cases of more than one parties, some of which fall below the monetary limit fixed for filing appeal in the forum of appeal.

 

3.         It is hereby clarified that the existing Instruction regarding applicability of monetary limits to cases of recurring nature would continue. Therefore, all cases, including cases of recurring nature, are covered under the Instruction on monetary limits and appeal is not to be filed in such cases except those falling in the two exclusion clauses mentioned above. Even if an appeal is pending in the higher appellate forum, subsequent case of the same party or other party shall not be pursued further in litigation if the case falls below the monetary limit prescribed by the Board. 

 

4.         The Instructions mentioned above used the word "case". However, the same was not defined. The term "case" needs to be interpreted in the context of National Litigation Policy which aims at reduction of litigation. In respect of a composite order which disposes of more than one appeal/SCN and the Department contemplates filing of appeal, every appeal would be a "case" and should be subjected to the threshold limit prescribed. To illustrate, if the Tribunal passes one composite order disposing of more than one appeal filed before it, and if the Department being aggrieved is required to file more than one appeal against the said Tribunal order, then each appeal shall be subject to the monetary limit prescribed. 

 

5.         There is no change in the monetary limits prescribed by the Board.

 

6.         The above clarification may be taken note of while processing appeals before the Tribunal and Courts. Difficulties faced, if any, may be brought to the notice of the Board.

 

( Archana P Tiwari)

Joint Secretary (Review)