News Flash
  • One-Day GST Training on “TDS provisions of Registration, Returns and Payments” for officers of CBIC on 24th August, 2018 at NACIN, Faridabad Click here
  • Notifications issued specifying the due dates for filing of FORM GSTR-1 and FORM GSTR-3B for the period from July, 2018 to March, 2019.
  • “The MPRs for Revenue Report (DDM-GST-1) and Revenue trend of Top 25 Assessees (DDM-GST-4) have been hosted on DDM website. GST Commissionerates are required to upload the Revenue Report [CHALLAN REVENUE] and Revenue trend of Top 25 Assessees data from July, 2017 to July, 2018 at the earliest. The DDM-GST-1A MPR are no longer required to be uploaded and hence disabled.”
  • Two Days' Course on "Vigilance Matters" for Group 'A' Officers of CBIC from 23.08.2018 to 24.08.2018 at NACIN Faridabad under training programme. Click here
  • Tracer dated 07.08.18 issued in respect of 60(sixty) bottle seals not received by Customs Kolkata Click here
  • Status of filling of Withdrawal applications before various Appellate FORA as required vide DO letter dt. 11.07.2018. Click here
  • Notifications issued specifying the special procedure for completion of migration of taxpayers who received provisional IDs but could not complete the migration process; and for exempting payment under reverse charge until 30.09.2019.
  • LIMBS FAQs for field formations under CBIC Click here
  • Updated version of GST Concept and Status and PPT on GST - An Update as on 01/08/2018 have been uploaded
  • One Week Training Programme for Gr-A Officers of CBIC on "Greening of Offices" at iCED, Jaipur from 27th to 31st August, 2018 Click here
  • Details of Prospective Trainings by NACIN and its ZTIs & RTIs in August 2018 Click here
  • Two Days' Training Programme on " Export Promotion Scheme - Pre & Post GST Era" for Gr-A Officers of CBIC on 16th & 17th August, 2018 at NACIN, Faridabad Click here
  • Letter from Chairman, CBIC for submission of Two Swachhta projects for the F.Y. 2018-19. Click here
  • Draft new GST return design, principles and formats is published on https://www.mygov.in/group-issue/simplified-gst-return-principles-and-draft-return-formats/ for feedback and suggestions till 31.08.2018
  • Letter from the office of DGHRD to all the CCAs reg initiation of "Online Deputation Module" for Group 'A' officers Click here   URL Address   Flow Chart
  • Draft GST returns and formats will be placed on Mygov.in portal shortly. Stakeholders are requested to provide their feedback on the MyGov portal.
  • Placing of GST Returns and formats in public domain - Reg. Click here
  • Chairman CBIC's newsletter dated 27.07.2018 Click here
  • Report called for Applications filed for withdrawal of cases in terms of instruction F.390/Misc./ 116/2017-JC dated 11.7.2018 Click here
  • Refund disposal fortnight to handhold trade and industry in clearing pending GST refund claims from 16.7.2018 to 31.7.2018 Click here
  • Video on SWACHH BHARAT - A Pune Customs Initiative. Click here
  • Member (GST) letter to all Pr. Chief Commissioners/Chief Commissioners of GST Zones for collecting GST related issues for MSME. Click here
  • Details of Prospective Trainings by NACIN and its ZTIs & RTIs in August, 2018 Click here
  • Postponement of two (2) days Train the Trainers (ToT) Workshop on Green Customs on 20-21 August,2018 which was earlier scheduled on 23- 24 July, 2018 Click here
  • Letter from the office of DGHRD to all the CCAs regarding initiation of Online Monitoring of DPC Module for Group B and C .Click here
  • Decisions taken by the GST Council in its meeting held on 21.07.2018 regarding GST rates on services and New Returns format.For detailsClick here
  • Chairman CBIC's newsletter dated 21.07.2018.Click here
  • Special instructions to PAO regarding GST Refunds.Click here
  • Observation of Swachhta Pakhwada in the Department Of Revenue from 15/10/18 to 31/10/18.Click here
  • Grievance Redressal Officers (CBIC and State / UT Governments) for e-way bill system under rule 138D of Central/ State GST Rules, 2017.Click here
  • Refund disposal fortnight to handhold trade and industry in clearing pending GST refund claims from 16.7.2018 to 31.7.2018.Click here
  • Three Days’ Training Programme on ‘DIGITAL FORENSICS’ for Group-‘A’ Officers of CBIC From 16th August to 18th August, 2018 at Gujarat Forensic Sciences University, Gandhinagar.Click here
  • All India Workshop on “Entrepreneurship, Empathy and Change: How to generate value in team and every ecosystem"Click here
  • Asset Accounting issues and poor upkeep of centrally supplied IT equipment Click here
  • DO letter dated 11/07/2018-Regarding raising of monetary limits for filing appeals by the Department before CESTAT/ High Courts and Supreme Court in Legacy Central Excise and Service Tax Click here
  • Raising of monetary limits for filing appeals by the Department before CESTAT/ High Courts and Supreme Court in Legacy Central Excise and Service Tax Click here
  • Methodology adopted for ranking of Zones/ Directorates/ Commissionerates under Swachhata Action Plan 2017-18 Click here
  • Extension of suspension of provisions relating to TDS and TCS till 30.09.2018Click here
  • Details of Prospective Trainings By NACIN and its ZTIs & RTIs in July, 2018 Click here
View all

F.No.390/Misc./163/2010-JC

Ministry of Finance

Department of Revenue

Central Board of Excise & Customs

*****

New Delhi 20th October 2010

 

INSTRUCTION 

To,

 

  1. All Chief Commissioners and Directors General under the Central Board of Excise and Customs.
  2. CDR, Customs, Excise & Service Tax Appellate Tribunal.
  3. All Commissioners of Customs/Central Excise/Service Tax/All Joint Chief Departmental Representatives/Commissioners, Directorate of Legal Affairs.
  4. <webmaster.cbec@icegate.gov.in>

 

Sub:-    Reduction of Government litigations - providing monetary limits for filing appeals by the Department before CESTAT and High Courts - Regarding

 

 

            The National Litigation Policy formulated by the Government of India aims to reduce Government litigation so that the Government ceases to be a compulsive litigant. The purpose underlying this Policy is to ensure that valuable time of the Courts is spent in resolving pending cases and in bringing down the average pendency time in the Courts. To achieve this, the Government should become an "efficient" and "responsible" litigant.

 2.         Accordingly the Policy lays down, inter alia, that in Revenue matters appeal shall not be filed if the amount involved is not very high and is less than the monetary limit fixed by the Revenue authorities. It also states that appeals shall not be filed if the matter is covered by a series of judgments of the Tribunal and the High Courts which have held the field and have not been challenged in the Supreme Court. The Policy also lays down that no appeal shall be filed where the assessee has acted in accordance with the long standing practice and also merely because of change of opinion on the part of the jurisdictional officers.

 3.         The Hon'ble Bombay High Court in its order dated 21.06.2010 in the case of CCE Vs Techno Economic Services Pvt. Ltd. [2010(255) ELT 526 (Bombay)] had desired that CBEC consider issuing circular, on the lines of circulars issued by the CBDT, so as to reduce litigations arising out of indirect tax litigations.

 4.         In respect of appeals filed in the Supreme Court, the proposals are examined by the Board before filing. The Civil Appeals on matters relating to valuation and classification are filed under Section 35L(b) of the Central Excise Act,1944 and Section 130E(b) of the Customs Act, 1962. Such appeals are being filed after careful scrutiny by the Board and while examining, the amount involved is kept in mind. On all issues other than those relating to valuation and classification, SLPs are filed by the Board after obtaining the opinion of the Ld. Law officer from the Ministry of Law. However, it may be mentioned that Board had issued Instruction vide DO F No. 390/170/92-JC dated 13.1.93 as modified by D.O. of even number dated 27.10.1993 advising the field formations that appeals should not be filed in the Supreme Court in cases where the duty involved is Rs 5 Lakhs or less. The said instruction was issued in the light of observation of the Supreme Court as conveyed by the then Ld Attorney General and was reiterated vide various Circulars issued by the Board from time to time. It is, therefore, desired that the above instruction must be kept in mind while sending proposals to the Board for filing civil appeal or SLP in the Supreme Court.

 5.         The Board has decided that appeals in the Tribunal shall not be filed where the duty involved or the total revenue including fine and penalty is Rs 1 Lakh and below.  Similarly in the case of High Courts appeals should not be filed in cases where the duty involved or total revenue including fine or penalty is Rs 2 lakhs and below.  While deciding the thresholds mentioned above, the duty involved shall be the decisive element. For example, in a case involving duty of Rs 1 lakh with mandatory penalty of Rs 1 lakh besides any other penalty imposed under the relevant provisions of Law, no appeal shall henceforth be filed in the Tribunal as the duty involved is within the monetary limit of Rs 1 lakh.   Similarly, if the duty involved in a case is Rs 2 lakhs with equal mandatory penalty and any other penalty imposed under the Law in force at the relevant time, no appeal shall be filed before the High Court.

 6.         Adverse judgments relating to the following should be contested irrespective of the amount involved:

a)   Where the constitutional validity of the provisions of an Act or Rule is under challenge.

b)   Where notification/instruction/order or Circular has been held illegal or ultra vires.

c)   Where audit objection on the issue involved in a case has been accepted by the Department


 7.         It may also be noted that, wherever it is decided not to file appeal in pursuance of these instructions, which are aimed solely at reducing Government litigation, such cases shall not have any precedent value.   In such cases, Commissioners should specifically record that "even though the decision is not acceptable, appeal is not being filed as the amount involved is less than the monetary limit prescribed by the Board."  Further, in such cases, there will be no presumption that the Department has acquiesced in the decision on the disputed issues in the case of same assessee or in case of any other assessees, if the amount involved exceeds the monetary limits.  Thus, in case any prior order is being cited on facts and law, it must be checked whether such order(s) were accepted only on account of the monetary limit before following them in the name of judicial discipline.

 8.         In respect of an order where it is decided not to file appeal in pursuance of these instructions, a data base needs to be created so that all the Commissionerates are made aware of the orders that are accepted solely on the ground that the revenue involved is below the threshold prescribed herein and which should not be taken as having precedent value. The details of such orders in respect of CESTAT and the High Courts is required to be furnished by the Zonal Chief Commissioners in Proforma enclosed (Annexure III E & Annexure III F) which should form part of the Monthly Technical Report being sent to the Directorate of Legal Affairs for posting on the departmental website. These Annexures III E and III F should be sent to the Directorate of Legal Affairs by e-mail also to

dla-rev@nic.in.

 9.         The above instructions of the Board must be adhered to strictly for all appeals filed on or after 1.11.2010.

 10.        Instruction issued vide F No. 275/55/CX 8A dated 10.11.2008 is hereby rescinded.

 11.        Hindi version follows.

 (Sunil K Sinha)

Director (Judicial & Review)

Click here for: Proforma (Annexure III E & Annexure III F).